Updated 30 September 2026 · AcademyCue Editorial Team
Manhattan Prep vs PrepScholar
Manhattan Prep
No. 3 of 19 in GRE, GMAT, LSAT and MCAT prep8.9Best for: GMAT, GRE or LSAT candidates who want course and tutoring from one screened, US based provider.

PrepScholar
No. 15 of 19 in GRE, GMAT, LSAT and MCAT prep8.7Best for: Students who want self-paced prep plus optional private tutoring from one provider.
Key differences
- Manhattan Prep scores higher overall: 8.9 against 8.7.
- Among support channels, only Manhattan Prep offers Community.
- Among exams, only Manhattan Prep offers Lsat.
- Among exams, only PrepScholar offers Sat and Act.
Side by side
PrepScholar | ||
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Price from | $300 to $999Lower | $397in the highest quarter of 51 providers |
| Prices by exam | Not listed | SAT: $397 (Complete Online SAT Prep); ACT: $397 (Complete Online ACT Prep); GRE: $38 for one-year access (GRE Adaptive Online Prep); GMAT: $139 (GMAT Online Prep, 3-month access), $259 (Complete GMAT Online Prep, 4-month access) |
| Offer | ||
| Access period | 3 to 12 months | 12 months |
| Live classes | Not listed | Yes |
| Practice questions | 1,200below the median of 32 providers | 4,700Higherin the highest quarter of 32 providers |
| Full-length practice tests | 4 to 6below the median of 25 providers | 8at the median of 25 providers |
| Free trial | Yes | Yes |
| Tutoring add-on | Not listed | Yes |
| Other facts | ||
| Exams | Gmat, Gre, Lsat | Sat, Act, Gre, Gmat |
| Score guarantee | Higher score | Money back |
| Guarantee terms | Score higher or your money back, 3/6/12 month plans only, conditions apply | 160+ point SAT (4+ point ACT, 7+ GRE, 60+ GMAT) improvement or full refund of the Complete Online Prep package; test taken within 60 days of finishing the course, refund request within 360 days of purchase, one refund per household |
| Money-back period | Not listed | 360 daysin the highest quarter of 34 providers |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | Kaplan, Inc. | PrepScholar Inc. |
| Headquarters | United States | United States |
| Founded | 2000 | 2013 |
| Support channels | Email, Phone, Help centre, Community | Email, Phone, Help centre |
| Tutoring | ||
| Lesson price from | Not listed | $105 |
| Subscription price | $300 to $999Lower | $1,598 |
| Trial lesson | Free | Free |
| Free trial length | Not listed | 5 days |
| Subjects | Not listed | Math, English, Science, School, Languages |
| Lesson format | 1to1, Group, App | 1to1, Group, App |
| Tutor vetting | Screened | Screened |
| Minimum age | Not listed | 13 |
| Cancellation notice | Not listed | 24 hours |
| Satisfaction guarantee | Score a 655 or raise your GMAT score by 70 points, depending on your baseline exam, or your money back | 160+ point SAT / 4+ point ACT money-back guarantee; 1-hour tutoring refund or free tutor switch if not satisfied |
Part scores
Manhattan Prep
Our verdict on each
Manhattan Prep
Manhattan Prep suits candidates who want a single US test prep name behind the GMAT, GRE and LSAT rather than a shelf of single-exam apps. Listed plan prices run $300 to $999, and the higher-score promise carries a money-back route on the longer plans, with conditions applied.
Read the full Manhattan Prep reviewPrepScholar
PrepScholar suits SAT and ACT students who want live classes and a money-back promise inside a single package. The Complete Online SAT Prep starts at $397 with 4,700 practice questions and 8 full length tests.
Read the full PrepScholar reviewIf neither fits
Pros and cons
Manhattan Prep
Pros
- The on-demand plan carries a higher score promise, and the guarantee terms add a money-back route on the longer plans.
- A single provider covers gmat, gre and lsat, so a candidate does not have to change company between exams.
- Tutors are vetted through screened and sessions run in 1to1, group and app formats, keeping private and group work with the same provider as the course.
Cons
- The guarantee terms attach the money-back route to the longer plans only, with conditions applied, so a shorter block has no refund on the same footing.
- Exam coverage stops at gmat, gre and lsat, so anyone sitting anything else has to look at a different provider.
- Access is sold in blocks of 3 to 12 months, so a candidate who needs less than a full block still pays for the rest of it.
PrepScholar
Pros
- The Complete Online SAT Prep and Complete Online ACT Prep are both listed at $397, so the headline cost does not change with the exam.
- Live classes are included, alongside 4,700 practice questions and 8 full length tests.
- The score promise is money back, and 360 days is the longest refund window in this ranking against a median of 30 days.
Cons
- Tutoring costs extra on top of the course price, since the tutoring addon is a yes rather than part of the base package.
Who each suits
Manhattan Prep
Who it suits
- Candidates sitting the GMAT, GRE or LSAT who want course and tutoring from the same provider.
- Learners who want their refund tied to a score outcome rather than to finishing the material.
- People who would rather phone or email than queue: support runs on email, phone and help centre.
Who should look elsewhere
- Not for the lowest outlay at entry: Testprep Training lists $12.99.
- Not for a single exam on a tight budget: Zebra Education starts at $49.
- Not for language exam candidates: E2Language lists $69 and targets a different exam from the gmat, gre and lsat covered here.
PrepScholar
Who it suits
- Students sitting the SAT or ACT who want one provider for both online prep and private tutoring.
- Learners who want live classes instead of app only study, since live classes are a yes here.
- Exam candidates who value a money back score promise over a cheap entry price.
Who should look elsewhere
- Testprep Training, where the entry price is $12.99 against $397 here.
- Zebra Education, whose entry price of $49 suits a narrower budget.
Current offers
Questions about each
Manhattan Prep
What does Manhattan Prep cost to enter, and what does it cost to renew?
Listed plan prices run $300 to $999, and the subscription price sits in the same band at $300 to $999, so a renewal is not marked down against the entry rate. That is a full price for exam prep rather than a budget line, and it sits well above Testprep Training at $12.99.
Is there a free trial before I pay?
A free trial is offered on the on-demand material, and the trial lesson itself is listed as free. A candidate can sample the question bank and the 4 to 6 full length tests before committing to a block of 3 to 12 months.
PrepScholar
How much does PrepScholar cost to start?
Entry price is $397 for the Complete Online SAT Prep, and the Complete Online ACT Prep sits at the same figure. The GRE Adaptive Online Prep and the GMAT Online Prep are priced lower and carry shorter access windows. Entry cost is the main thing to weigh, since 47 of 65 brands start at a higher figure.
What does PrepScholar include in a course package?
A package covers 12 months of access, 4,700 practice questions and 8 full length tests, with live classes included. Private tutoring is available as an addon rather than inside the base price. Subjects covered by the tutoring side include maths, English, science, school work and languages.
